Tim Hortons Harry Potter Donuts Ranked: Which One Is Best?

Gryffindor Strawberry Cheesecake Donut

The Gryffindor donut does something none of the other three do - it uses two fillings. One side has a strawberry rhubarb jam. The other has a cream cheese filling. When you bite through the middle and get both at once, that's where this donut becomes something special. The fruity sweetness of the strawberry hits first, then the tangy cream cheese rounds it out. It tastes like an actual strawberry cheesecake.

The topping is white fondant with small strawberry-flavoured bark pieces scattered across the surface. They add a subtle crunch - not the heavy, artificial kind, more like a light snap that breaks up the softness of the yeast dough. The house crest sits cleanly on top.

What makes it rank #1 is the balance. Most filled donuts are sweet on sweet on sweet. This one has that cream cheese tang cutting through the sugar, so you actually want to finish the whole thing without feeling overwhelmed. That contrast is rare in a fast-food donut.

It's also the lightest at 290 calories and 9g of fat. So if you're only trying one Harry Potter donut, this is the one. No question.

Hufflepuff Lemon Meringue Donut

The Hufflepuff has become a genuine fan favourite - and not just among lemon lovers. Across Reddit and social media, it consistently ranks in the top two, with many people calling it the best donut in the whole collection. That surprised us too.

The filling is a two-part combination: lemon custard and vanilla fluff. The lemon custard is genuinely tart - not a wimpy, vaguely citrus paste. It tastes like real lemon curd. The vanilla fluff adds a marshmallow-like creaminess that softens the citrus bite, creating something that actually resembles lemon meringue pie in donut form.

The yellow fondant is topped with meringue-flavoured sugar crunch pieces. They're slightly sweeter than the Krunch on the other donuts, which helps balance the tartness. The combination of tart filling and sweet topping is what makes this one work so well.

At 330 calories and 13g of fat, it's heavier than Gryffindor or Ravenclaw. But the flavour profile is more interesting than either - the lemon-vanilla contrast gives it real depth that a single-filling donut can't match.

It ranks #2 rather than #1 because it's still a flavour that divides people. If you don't like citrus desserts, you won't enjoy this - and that narrower audience keeps it just behind the universally-liked Gryffindor. But if lemon meringue pie is your thing, this might be your #1.

Ravenclaw Blueberry Donut

The Ravenclaw is the most familiar donut in the collection - it's a blueberry filled yeast donut, which is something Tim Hortons has done before. If you've ever had a good blueberry donut from a bakery, this tastes like that, with better presentation.

The blueberry filling is sweet and tastes like actual blueberries, not artificial blue candy. The topping is bright blue fondant with blue sugar Krunch pieces that add small, crunchy bits of texture against the soft yeast dough. It's a simple flavour profile done competently.

The reason it drops to #3 is a word that keeps coming up in reviews: “mid.”Many fans on Reddit and social media found the Ravenclaw underwhelming compared to the other three. It's not bad - nobody is calling it unpleasant - but it doesn't have a wow factor. The blueberry is blueberry from first bite to last. No second flavour, no contrast, no surprise.

At 300 calories and just 8g of fat, it's the lowest-fat option. If you want the lightest Harry Potter donut and prefer safe, familiar flavours, the Ravenclaw won't let you down. But it won't wow you either.

Slytherin Chocolate Pistachio Donut

On paper, this sounds like the best donut in the lineup. Chocolate fudge filling. Pistachio spread. Crunchy green topping. It's the kind of flavour combination you'd pay $8 for at a fancy bakery. But in execution, it doesn't quite land the way you want it to.

The chocolate fudge filling is dense. Really dense. It's rich, deeply sweet, and coats your mouth in a way that the fruit-based donuts don't. The pistachio spread sits on top under the fondant, adding a nutty layer - but in most bites, the chocolate dominates. You have to deliberately get a section with a thick layer of pistachio to taste it clearly.

The green Krunch topping is the weakest of the four toppings. It adds crunch but very little flavour of its own. Visually it looks great - very Slytherin. But it doesn't contribute to the taste profile the way the strawberry bark does on Gryffindor or the meringue crunch does on Hufflepuff.

At 340 calories and 15g of fat, this is the heaviest donut by a clear margin. The sugar is actually the lowest at 21g, but the high fat content makes it feel heavier than the numbers suggest. If you eat the whole thing quickly, it can feel like a lot.

It ranks last not because it's bad - the chocolate fudge is genuinely good chocolate - but because the pistachio gets lost, the topping underperforms, and the heaviness works against it when compared side-by-side with the others. If you're a serious chocolate person who doesn't care about calorie count, you might actually rank this one higher. But for most people, it's the one they try once.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Here's how all four stack up side by side. The calorie and fat differences are bigger than you'd expect between donuts that look nearly the same size.

All four donuts cost $2.79. Nutrition is per donut.

Best Drink to Pair with Each Donut

The Harry Potter menu also includes four Quencher drinks - each made with blueberry-raspberry juice, served in colour-changing cups. Here's which drink works best with which donut.

Tips Before You Order

The Final Verdict

There are no bad donuts in this collection. All four are well-made, visually stunning, and fairly priced at $2.79 - you're not paying a premium for the Harry Potter branding. The edible house crests are a nice touch, and the custom packaging makes them feel like an event rather than just a donut run.

Gryffindor wins because it has the most interesting filling, the best balance, and the lowest calorie count. But honestly, the gap between #1 and #4 is smaller than you'd think. If you're a chocolate person, the Slytherin might be your #1. If you're a citrus person, the Hufflepuff will rank higher for you.

The best move is to grab a 6-Pack, try all four, and rank them yourself. For full prices, nutrition, and the complete Harry Potter lineup including drinks and collectibles, visit the Tim Hortons menu.

Other Harry Potter Menu Items

The donuts are just one part of the collection. Here's everything else on the Harry Potter menu - drinks, Timbits, donut packs, and collectible merchandise.

Golden Snitch Caramel Timbit

$0.49

Patronus Sparkling Quencher

From $3.49

Patronus Lemonade Quencher

From $2.49

Patronus Frozen Quencher

From $3.49

Forbidden Forest Iced Tea Quencher

From $2.49

Hogwarts 6-Pack

$11.99

Hogwarts 12-Pack

$19.99

Golden Snitch Timbits Holder with 10 Timbits

$17.99

Golden Snitch Timbits Holder

$14.99

Colour Changing Stir Wand

$19.99

Frequently Asked Questions